Nestled in the heart of McAlester at 606 E Wyandotte Ave, Buffalos Cafe & Pizzeria welcomes you with the aroma of authentic, homemade pizza and classic diner favorites. Whether you're craving a hearty breakfast served all day or a quick, satisfying lunch, our cozy, casual spot offers it all. Known for generous portions and friendly service, we create a warm community hub where locals and travelers feel at home. Bring your family, meet friends, or enjoy a solo bite—our welcoming atmosphere and tasty offerings make every visit memorable. We pride ourselves on using fresh ingredients, delivering great value, and embracing the town spirit you find when stepping into McAlester’s favorite diner.
Welcome to Buffalos Cafe & Pizzeria
Experience the finest dining




Nestled in the heart of McAlester, Oklahoma, Buffalos Cafe & Pizzeria offers a welcoming escape for locals and travelers alike. Our cozy diner-style spot serves up hearty breakfast all day, satisfying lunch cravings, and delicious dinners in a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. From the aroma of freshly baked pizza to the sizzle of classic breakfast dishes, we focus on comfort food made right. Our community loves the generous portions, affordable prices—most dishes under $10—and the warm service that makes everyone feel at home. Whether you're popping in for a quick breakfast, a hearty lunch, or a family dinner, Buffalos is your go-to spot. We take pride in offering local specialties and a vibe that invites you to linger, chat with friends, or enjoy solo dining. Come see why so many call us their favorite local diner!”},{
section_heading":"Features at Buffalos Cafe & Pizzeria"
section_content
features_section_1
features_section_2
Buffalos Cafe & Pizzeria stands out as a cornerstone of McAlester’s food scene since opening. We blend traditional diner comfort with the craft of homemade pizzas baked fresh daily. Our kitchen whips up breakfast all day—perfect for early birds and night owls alike—plus satisfying lunch and dinner options that keep our community coming back. Our menu features classics like chicken fried steak, calzones, fresh salads, and dessert pies—all served with the friendly service and inviting atmosphere you expect from a small-town gem. We support local farmers and vendors, sourcing ingredients for that authentic, homemade taste. Cleanliness and safety remain a top priority, following all local health standards. Our focus is your satisfaction, whether you dine in or take away. Over the years, we’ve built a reputation for quality, affordability, and friendliness, making Buffalos a place where everyone belongs.”},{
section_heading":"Buffalos Exterior, Outdoor, Vibe"
section_content
Our restaurant radiates a casual, inviting vibe. The cheerful signage complements the rarely busy outdoor seating area perfect for sunny Oklahoma days. Inside, warm lighting and rustic decor create a cozy, small-town atmosphere. Locals often gather at the counter or around tables, sharing stories over piping hot coffee or slices of pizza. The friendly staff makes you feel like part of the neighborhood from the moment you arrive. Whether you’re here for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, the vibe encourages community. We’re proud of our accessible parking, welcoming everyone—including families with kids—into our friendly, laid-back space.
section_heading":"Buffalos Commitment, Specialty, Vision"
section_content
At Buffalos, our vision centers on serving quality, comfort-driven food rooted in community values. We’re committed to supporting local producers and creating a space where families, friends, and solo diners feel at home. Our specialties include homemade pizzas—available in a pizza buffet Monday-Friday from 11 am to 1 pm—and traditional diner classics like chicken fried steak and breakfast all day. We aim to bring people together around good food, exceptional service, and a warm atmosphere. Accessibility is key; our restaurant features wheelchair-accessible facilities to serve everyone. We see ourselves not just as a restaurant but as an integral part of McAlester’s social fabric—offering affordability, consistency, and a genuine hometown experience.
Location & Contact
The Setting
Address
606 E Wyandotte Ave, McAlester, OK 74501, United States
Phone
+1 918-426-6255
About
The Journey Behind the Flavor





At Buffalos, we serve more than just food—we serve an experience. Our menu features traditional diner dishes alongside flavorful, homemade pizzas. Indulge in breakfast any time of day, with options from fluffy biscuits and gravy to savory omelets. Our pizza buffet, available Monday through Friday from 11 am to 1 pm, provides an endless variety of fresh, hot pizzas—perfect for groups or hungry individuals.
We prioritize friendly, attentive service, quick turnaround, and a cozy ambiance. Our location offers wheelchair-accessible parking, entrances, and seating to ensure everyone feels comfortable. Plus, our affordable prices keep you coming back without breaking the bank. Whether it’s an early breakfast, a quick lunch, or a relaxed dinner, Buffalos delivers comfort food in a community-centered setting.
Work Hours
Reservations & Service Hours
- SundayClosed
- Monday6 AM–2 PM
- Tuesday6 AM–2 PM
- Wednesday6 AM–2 PM
- Thursday6 AM–2 PM
- Friday6 AM–2 PM
- Saturday6 AM–2 PM
Guestbook & Reviews
Customer Reviews
Loved the food! The portion sizes were just right for the price, and the service was excellent—friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Such a great little diner with a warm, inviting atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!
I went under previous owners once and didn't go back. Recently tried it and was very impressed. I had the chicken fried steak sandwich and okra. Both were hot and crispy not greasy. The owner visited our table and was open to feedback that the steak needs a little more pepper.
Had the steak and egg breakfast this morning. i ordered a medium rare steak and over medium eggs and both were cooked just the way I ordered them. Good flavor and a good price too!
As soon as you walk in, you get a small town welcome and a great atmosphere. The owner greets everyone and really makes you feel like part of the town. The amount of food you get for 10 bucks is incredible and it tastes great. Immediately saved as a favorite location afterwards
Stop here on my way back to Houston, Waitress are very kind. The price was reasonable. Food was so yummy. I had to take my half, food portion are big. Next time i pass through Oklahoma i will stop by.
They need to hire more staff. Wait times were long & waitresses wore thin. However, the food was spectacular! They serve breakfast all day.






